|
|
Post by salamo on Aug 8, 2016 4:43:22 GMT -8
Dusk Assault Sallet +9520 hp
+567 cs
+851 pen
+747 def
Dusk Raid Greaves +9520 hp
+851 pow
+567 cs
+747 def
Set bonus (when grouped) +5000 hp +1000 pow +1000 def
Total hp 9520 + 9520 + 5000 = 24040 Total pow 0 + 851 + 1000 = 1851 Total def 747 + 747 + 1000 = 2494 (also adds +623 power due to 25% feat bonus)
Total pen 851 + 0 + 0 = 851 Total cs 567 + 567 + 0 = 1134
Real power 25%(2494) + 1851 = 2474 Compensated Power = 2474 + 200 = 2674 (+19) Compensated Critical = 1134 + 600 = 1734 (-157)
versus
Elemental Alliance Assault Sallet
+8899 hp
+1242 cs
+532 pen
+724 def
Elemental Dragonflight Raid Greaves +10968 hp
+974 pow
+649 cs
+802 def
Set bonus (Always) +2000 hp +500 pow
Total hp 8899 + 10968 + 2000 = 21867
Total pow 0 + 974 + 500 = 1474
Total def 724 + 802 + 0 = 1526
Total pen 532 + 0 + 0 = 532
Total cs 1242 + 649 + 0 = 1891
Real power 25%(1526)+1474 = 1855 Compensated Power = 1855 + 800 = 2655 (-19)
Compensated Critical = 1891 + 0 = 1891 (+157)
So the Dusk set has the better effective stats overall with the exception of critical strike. The 3 pcs set has 757 more critical strike at the cost of 619 power. So compensation wise you would need Major Critical Armor Kits for the Dusk set and Major Power Armor Kits for the 3pcs set. That would give the 3pcs set 181 power advantage at the cost of 43 crititcal (or equal-ish power at 1 power/2crit kits at advantage of 157 crit).
Overall I would say the Dusk set combo yields a far better return* due to the other stat bonusses then the little crit difference between the two at an equal compensated power ratio. Especially when you take into account further compensation options when using insignias.
Dusk set net advantage: +2173 hp +19 pow (nett.) +980 defense +319 armor penetration
Dusk set net disadvantage: -157 critical strike
|
|
|
|
Post by memigen on Aug 8, 2016 10:09:00 GMT -8
I agree that a half and half set is best. This is what I run and I see many do the same. It just seems to yield better results overall.  |
|
|
|
Post by salamo on Aug 8, 2016 23:53:23 GMT -8
I did these calcs for a discussion I had with Neo on the subject, imho these calcs proof that the dusk set / df set combo is the better choice. The 3 pcs DF set yields a far higher crit potential though. If that is what you need it may be better. I personally like higher stats accross the board though.
|
|
|
|
Post by phoebee on Aug 9, 2016 9:10:45 GMT -8
It's been a good discussion - and it's great to see the #s side by side Sal thx!!
|
|
|
|
Post by salamo on Aug 10, 2016 4:53:37 GMT -8
If you take the comparison and focus on critical strike alone the numbers work out like this:
Dusk Assault Sallet
+9520 hp
+567 cs
+851 pen
+747 def
Dusk Raid Greaves
+9520 hp
+851 pow
+567 cs
+747 def
Set bonus (when grouped)
+5000 hp
+1000 pow
+1000 def
Total hp 9520 + 9520 + 5000 = 24040
Total pow 0 + 851 + 1000 = 1851
Total def 747 + 747 + 1000 = 2494 (also adds +623 power due to 25% feat bonus)
Total pen 851 + 0 + 0 = 851
Total cs 567 + 567 + 0 = 1134
Real power 25%(2494) + 1851 = 2474
Compensated Power = 2474 + 0 = 2474 (+619)
Compensated Critical = 1134 + 800 = 1934 (-757)
versus
Elemental Alliance Assault Sallet
+8899 hp
+1242 cs
+532 pen
+724 def
Elemental Dragonflight Raid Greaves
+10968 hp
+974 pow
+649 cs
+802 def
Set bonus (Always)
+2000 hp
+500 pow
Total hp 8899 + 10968 + 2000 = 21867
Total pow 0 + 974 + 500 = 1474
Total def 724 + 802 + 0 = 1526
Total pen 532 + 0 + 0 = 532
Total cs 1242 + 649 + 0 = 1891
Real power 25%(1526)+1474 = 1855
Compensated Power = 1855 + 0 = 1855 (-619)
Compensated Critical = 1891 + 800 = 2691 (+757)
From a pure critical strike perspective, the DF 3pcs set seems to be the way to go. That said there is another way of compensating critical strike; which is insignias (+1000 critical should be possible through mounts, expensive, yes).
DF 3pcs set net advantage:
+757 critical strike
DF 3pcs set net disadvantage:
-2173 hp
-619 pow (nett.)
-980 defense
-319 armor penetration
Stats wise there is another set to examine which is the Adamant Set (+3 il per piece versus elemental df, +10 per dusk piece, +13 for the el alliance assault piece, so +26 for the dusk set and +22 for the 3pcs set).
|
|
|
|
Post by salamo on Aug 19, 2016 8:48:16 GMT -8
|
|
|
|
Post by phoebee on Aug 19, 2016 17:45:03 GMT -8
Spreadsheets!!!! ***swoon*** right on!!! TY
|
|
|
|
Post by salamo on Aug 22, 2016 16:55:57 GMT -8
Soooooo made a big boo-boo in my math... here's the new one. Attachments:
|
|
|
|
Post by phoebee on Aug 23, 2016 20:21:19 GMT -8
A big one - snickers
|
|
